TEXT-S&P cuts 3 Bear Stearns Commercial Mortgage 2005-PWR9 ratings
18.05.12
April 25 - OVERVIEW
-- We lowered our ratings on three classes from Bear Stearns Commercial
Mortgage Securities Trust 2005-PWR9, a U.S. CMBS transaction.
-- In addition, we affirmed our ratings on 11 other classes from the same
transaction.
-- The downgrades reflect credit deterioration within the collateral pool
and credit support erosion that we anticipate will occur upon the eventual
resolution of eight of the transaction's 10 loans that are currently with the
special servicer.
NEW YORK (Standard & Poor's) April 25, 2012--Standard & Poor's Ratings
Services today lowered its ratings on three classes of commercial mortgage
pass-through certificates from Bear Stearns Commercial Mortgage Securities
Trust 2005-PWR9, a U.S. commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS)
transaction. Concurrently, we affirmed our ratings on 11 other classes from
the same transaction (see list).
The downgrades reflect deterioration in the credit characteristics of the pool
collateral, which under our 'AAA' scenario, yielded debt service coverage
(DSC) of 0.92x and a (loan-to-value) ratio of 161.0%. The downgrades further
reflect credit support erosion that we anticipate will occur upon the eventual
resolution of eight ($93.4 million, 5.2%) of the transaction's 10 ($112.2
million, 6.3%) loans that are currently with the special servicer.
The affirmed ratings on the principal and interest certificates reflect
subordination and liquidity support levels that are consistent with the
outstanding ratings. We affirmed our 'AAA (sf)' ratings on the class X-1 and
X-2 interest-only (IO) certificates based on our current criteria.
Using servicer-provided financial information, we calculated an adjusted DSC
of 1.36x and a LTV ratio of 122.7%. We further stressed the loans' cash flows
under our 'AAA' scenario to yield a weighted average DSC of 0.92x and an LTV
ratio of 161.0%. The implied defaults and loss severity under the 'AAA'
scenario were 76.1% and 37.0%, respectively. These DSC and LTV calculations
exclude nine defeased loans ($101.9 million, 5.7%) and eight ($93.4 million,
5.2%) of the transaction's 10 ($112.2 million, 6.3%) loans that are currently
with the special servicer. We separately estimated losses for these loans and
included them in our 'AAA' scenario implied default and loss severity figures.
CREDIT CONSIDERATIONS
As of the April 11, 2012, trustee remittance report, eight ($95.2 million,
5.3%) loans in the pool were with the special servicer, Situs Holdings LLC
(Situs). According to Situs, two additional loans, the Vista Plaza loan ($2.0
million, 0.1%) and the Baker Waterfront Plaza loan ($15.0 million, 0.9%), were
transferred to special servicing subsequent to the April 2012 trustee
remittance report. The reported payment status of the specially serviced loans
is as follows: one is in foreclosure ($5.2 million, 0.3%), six are 90-plus
days delinquent ($62.3 million, 3.5%), one is 60 days delinquent ($2.0
million, 0.1%) and two are current ($42.7 million, 2.4%). Appraisal reduction
amounts (ARAs) totaling $34.6 million are in effect for seven of the specially
serviced loans. Details on the three largest loans currently with the special
servicer are as follows:
The 2 & 4 Gannett Drive loan ($27.7 million, 1.5%), the largest specially
serviced loan, is secured by two office buildings in Harrison, N.Y., totaling
219,000 sq. ft. The loan, which has a reported current payment status, was
transferred to the special servicer on Jan. 28, 2011, due to imminent default.
The reported DSC was 0.60x as of year-end 2011. According to Situs,
negotiations for a discounted payoff (DPO) with the borrower are ongoing. We
expect a moderate loss upon the eventual resolution of this loan.
The Storage Bin Portfolio loan ($24.9 million, 1.4%), the second-largest
specially serviced loan, is collateralized by a portfolio of five self-storage
properties totaling 311,000 sq. ft. (2,741 units) in Southern New Jersey and
Southeast Pennsylvania (two of the properties are first phases of a two-phase
project). The loan has a reported 90-plus-days delinquent payment status and
has a total reported exposure of $27.1 million. The loan was transferred to
the special servicer on Oct. 11, 2010, due to imminent default. An ARA of
$16.8 million is in effect against this loan. According to Situs, it has
approved a final business plan that permits a DPO, which is being documented,
in the amount of $17.0 million ($12.0 million plus an existing $5.0 million
letter of credit). The borrower's year-end 2011 operating statements reported
an effective gross income of $2.2 million, operating expenses of $1.3 million,
net operating income of $916,000, and net cash flow of $870,000. The year-end
2011 reported DSC was 0.46x. We expect a significant loss upon the eventual
resolution of this loan.
The Baker Waterfront Plaza loan ($15.0 million, 0.9%), the third-largest loan
with the special servicer, is secured by a 92,821-sq.-ft. office building in
Hoboken, N.J. The loan, which has a reported current payment status, was
transferred to special servicing due to imminent default on April 12, 2012.RELATED CRITERIA AND RESEARCH
-- Global Structured Finance Scenario And Sensitivity Analysis: The
Effects Of The Top Five Macroeconomic Factors, published Nov. 4, 2011.
-- U.S. Government Support In Structured Finance And Public Finance
Ratings, published Sept. 19, 2011.
-- Updated Defeasance Criteria For U.S. CMBS Transactions, published Aug.
16, 2011.
-- U.S. CMBS Rating Methodology And Assumptions For Conduit/Fusion Pools,
published Nov. 3, 2010.
-- Methodology And Assumptions For Analyzing The Major Property Types In
U.S. CMBS Transactions, published June 14, 2010.
-- Global Methodology For Rating Interest-Only Securities, published
April 15, 2010.
-- U.S. CMBS 'AAA' Scenario Loss And Recovery Application, published July
21, 2009.
-- Standard & Poor's Defeasance Criteria For U.S. CMBS Transactions,
published April 4, 2003.
RATINGS LOWERED
Bear Stearns Commercial Mortgage Securities Trust 2005-PWR9
Commercial mortgage pass-through certificates
Rating
Class To From Credit enhancement (%)
C BB+ (sf) BBB- (sf) 10.89
D BB- (sf) BB (sf) 9.54
E B (sf) B+ (sf) 7.89
RATINGS AFFIRMED
Bear Stearns Commercial Mortgage Securities Trust 2005-PWR9
Commercial mortgage pass-through certificates
Class Rating Credit enhancement (%)
A-2 AAA (sf) 22.90
A-3 AAA (sf) 22.90
A-AB AAA (sf) 22.90
A-4A AAA (sf) 32.53
A-4B AA (sf) 22.90
A-1A AA (sf) 22.90
A-J BBB+ (sf) 13.59
B BBB (sf) 12.84
F CCC- (sf) 6.69
X-1 AAA (sf) N/A
X-2 AAA (sf) N/A
N/A--Not applicable.
Source: Reuters
Foreclosures on rise in 2012
18.05.12
Wells Fargo Bank recently foreclosed on Baxter resident Mary Bowlin’s former home in north Macclenny, one of 46 properties in Baker County that received foreclosure notices in the first quarter of this year.
The 79-year-old widow fell behind on the $1500-a-month mortgage payments for her two bedroom home on Linda Street after her husband died in 2010.
Ms. Bowlin said the payments to Wells Fargo jumped “a few hundred dollars” sometime before her husband’s death.
“They kept calling and I told them I couldn’t make the payments and to just go ahead and put in the foreclosure, so I just moved out,” she said. Ms. Bowlin has now moved back to the north county, where she grew up, to be closer to family.
Foreclosures filings fell nationwide by 16 percent in the first quarter of 2012, but jumped in Florida, and even more so in Baker County, compared to the same quarter last year.
Foreclosures rose about 26 percent statewide, but more than doubled in Baker County from 18 foreclosure notices in the first quarter of 2011 to 46 in the first quarter of 2012.
Source: Baker County Press